Book Review: Scythe – Neal Shusterman


Title: Scythe (2016)
Series: Arc of a Scythe – Book 1
Author: Neal Shusterman
Publisher: Simon & Schuster
Genre: Young Adult, Science Fiction, Dystopian Fiction
Extent: 448 pages
Release Date: November 22, 2016
Rating: ★★★★☆

Goodreads Description

In a world where disease has been eliminated, the only way to die is to be randomly killed (“gleaned”) by professional reapers (“scythes”). Citra and Rowan are teenagers who have been selected to be scythe’s apprentices, and—despite wanting nothing to do with the vocation—they must learn the art of killing and come to understand the necessity of what they do.

Only one of them will be chosen as a scythe’s apprentice. And when it becomes clear that the winning apprentice’s first task will be to glean the loser, Citra and Rowan are pitted against one another in a fight for their lives.


So, funny story: I started writing this review quite a few weeks after finishing it, fully intending to give it a half-star lower than what I ended up, and as I was writing, I realised just how much I really enjoyed this book. The flaws I thought were flaws began to minimise, while things I loved expanded and took centre stage. Somehow, Scythe is the book I always wanted to read but never knew I wanted to read. Interesting, isn’t it, how a book can do that to you? 🤔

Scythe is set in a future world where human life is as close to ‘perfect’ as it can be: disease no longer exists, government has been replaced by an all-knowing, neutral AI called the Thunderhead, and humans live forever… that is, unless they are chosen to die by ‘scythes’, humans chosen to be professional reapers.

To date, the oldest living human being is somewhere around three hundred, but only because we are still so close to the Age of Mortality. I wonder what life will be like a millennium from now, when the average age will be nearer to one thousand. Will we all be renaissance children, skilled at every art and science, because we’ve had the time to master them? Or will boredom and slavish routine plague us even more than it does today, giving us less of a reason to live limitless lives? I dream of the former, but suspect the latter.

Pardon my inner geek for anything futuristic, but this is so cool, you guys. I could poke loopholes in the premise, but why would I want to? I enjoyed what it has to offer so much that I took everything in stride. It’s pretty much the dystopian utopia I had always imagined —  it’s dark, violent, and morbid, and yet also rather tongue-in-cheek, and it made me feel unsettled yet also incredibly, incredibly intrigued.

Our main characters are Citra and Rowan, two teenagers chosen by Scythe Faraday to be his apprentices. We follow them as they learn to become killers and realise both the benefits and consequences of being one. Throw in some politics and deception, some journal entries written by scythes, some humour, and a sprinkling of romance, and you’ve got Scythe. Also, the future is not so different after all:

“The Scythe Archive is open to everyone.”

“Yeah,” said Rowan, “like the Thunderhead. People can read anything, but no one does. All they do is play games and watch cat holograms.”

Scythe is what I would call ‘cheerfully gory’. It’s a book where murder is a sport, and murderers are given somewhat of a godly status hailed above everyone else, and so is surprisingly philosophical, bringing to light questions about human nature and life and death. In a world where death is necessary but no one dies, is murder still ‘wrong’, especially if it’s mandated and encouraged by an all-knowing being? Things like morals and law may not be so fixed, after all.

What I wish was better were the characters and the romance. While I like the main characters, they felt… simple, for lack of a better word. They were predictable in what they did and thought and never once surprised me. They were also, unfortunately, kind of black-and-white in a way I didn’t expect characters in such a grey book to be. The romance also felt shallow and young, but that’s probably on me. (It was cute, though. 😂)

“I haven’t fallen in love with you, Rowan. And now I want to keep it that way.”

Rowan got up and moved to the safety of the threshold before turning back to her. “It’s all right, Citra,” he told her. “I haven’t fallen in love with you either.”

Thankfully these flaws were inconsequential enough that Scythe overall was intriguing and entertaining for me. While predictable at parts, the plot is fast, gripping and action-packed, and the world-building felt futuristic yet plausible — I simply enjoyed it. ❤️

78 thoughts on “Book Review: Scythe – Neal Shusterman

  1. Lovely review, Reg! I have been having a bit of a hard time with dystopia lately, to be honest I haven’t picked up a book in the genre for a couple months. After reading tons, they all feel the same. However, I’m really curious about that world and glad to hear you enjoyed it so much despite the little flaws you found in the book 🙂


  2. Great review Reg! I had this book in my hands last weekend at B&N doing my little dance of “Should I ? Should I not?” LOL ultimately I convinced myself to order it online which I forgot to do by the time I got back home smh. You’ve reminded me to buy this book already, I didn’t know that Scythe is book 1 in a series. I’m curious about the journal entries and gory humor, hope the characters/romance improve though cuz that can make or break a book for me 😉


  3. Great review for this book Reg! I’ve been seeing this book around a lot recently but haven’t been sure whether I should pick it up or not. I think your review has convinced me I should. I love the sound of the world it’s set in, a place where no one can die, where murderers are given a kind of godly status, and where two teens are chosen as reapers so to say. Plus I’m kind of intrigued by the tongue in cheek humour you mentioned as well.
    I’m definitely going to have to pick up this book soon. I’m sorry the characters and the romance weren’t as good for you as the world building was, but overall it still seems like a great read! 😀


  4. Great review! This definitely sounds like my cup of tea. And isn’t that crazy how sometimes it takes a bit before our true feelings about a book really start to sink in? Awesome. So happy to hear you liked it!


  5. Nice review! Like you,my feelings about this book seem to have gotten more positive with distance. I think I may have set my expectations a little too high because of how much I love Shusterman’s other novels.

    I love how you describe the novel as “cheerfully gory.” I never would have thought to describe it that way, but it’s so true.


    • Thank you, Jacqueline! I haven’t read any of Shusterman’s other novels, so this was my first and I must say I’m quite impressed. What would you recommend from him?

      And I’m glad you agree with that description! I just thought it fitting bc the book was so flippant about death and murder. 😂

      Liked by 1 person

      • My favorite is probably Neal Shusterman’s Unwind Dystology, which is his other dystopian series, but his standalone contemporary Challenger Deep is very good as well, but hard to read at times due to the difficult subject matter and unusual formatting.

        Yeah, it was interesting how death and murder were addressed. I don’t think the only other place I’ve seen death so casually mentioned is video games.


    • It did! I just loved the world so much – it was what I imagined a (dysfunctional) utopia to be like in the future, haha. I mean, I’ve imagined a similar world in my head, and it was interesting to see it play out on paper. I hope you give it a chance. 💞

      Liked by 1 person

  6. I love the sound of this book! A world where humans are nearly immortal and certain people are given the job to kill? I don’t think I’ve read anything like that before. And I love books that are set in a futuristic place. Although it sucks that the characters were a bit predictable but either way I’m definitely adding it to my TBR because I’m curious about the world. Great review, Reg! 😊


  7. Amazing review! I haven’t heard of this book before now, but it definitely sound like something I like to read. I like them dark fantasies haha. The plot is unique and it definitely piques my interest. I’ll have to add this one onto my TBR. Thanks for the review! 😀


  8. Great review! I’ve seen surprisingly few bloggers talking about this book but it sounds great and quite unique so I definitely want to read it.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s