Mini Reviews Monday: Hello, Goodbye and Everything in Between (Jennifer E. Smith) + Skyscraping (Cordelia Jensen)

feature_minireviewsmonday

Welcome to Mini Reviews Monday, a She Latitude weekly feature! This is for those books that don’t really require a full-fledged review and is a way for me to really just take note and keep track of all the books I’m reading. This week we start with Hello, Goodbye and Everything in Between by Jennifer E. Smith and Skyscraping by Cordelia Jensen.


Hello Goodbye EverythingHello, Goodbye and Everything in Between | Jennifer E. Smith (2015)
Young Adult, Contemporary | 246 pages | ★★☆☆☆

What it’s about: A teenage couple tries to decide whether to break up or to stay together since they’re leaving for college tomorrow and will soon have thousands of miles between them. Cue a night of visiting the places that mean something to them in the two years they have been together.

What’s good: It’s pretty fast-paced, and people who are on the brink of leaving for college would probably find something to enjoy about it. The love interest is likeable enough that I sure want him to be happy. And for a story that’s told over just one night, it’s definitely quite entertaining at some parts.

What’s bad: Clare, the main protagonist, is pretty self-centred, and I wasn’t impressed by how she makes everything about her. She gets called out for it later on but at that point it was a bit too late for me to fall in love with her. Additionally, the ending was unsatisfying and made the whole book just seem kind of pointless.

Verdict: Quick, easy read, but didn’t really leave much of an impression.


SkyscrapingSkyscraping | Cordelia Jensen (2015)
Young Adult, Contemporary | 352 pages | ★★☆☆☆

What it’s about: A girl finds out that her parents have an open marriage and her dad is actually gay, and while she tries to cope with it, discovers that he is also HIV-positive. Told in verse.

What’s good: It tackles a very real, very important issue. It’s set in the 1990s, so it’s definitely not as contemporary as other contemporary YA books, but I like that it tried something different. Some parts of the book were really heartbreaking. There’s no real love interest, which is good because in this case, it personally would have distracted from the main message.

What’s bad: It’s told in verse, a decision I don’t see the point of. The main character, Mira, is a bit self-centred and immature, and I sometimes wish that her younger sister April was the main character instead. Some of the subplots weren’t necessary and just didn’t really add anything to the story.

Verdict: I would probably love this book if it was written in prose. I just didn’t really connect with the verse that much.

Advertisements

6 thoughts on “Mini Reviews Monday: Hello, Goodbye and Everything in Between (Jennifer E. Smith) + Skyscraping (Cordelia Jensen)

  1. I actually really enjoyed Hello, Goodbye and Everything In Between (but I love all of Jennifer E. Smith’s books). But I agree with your thoughts on Clare. I didn’t really understand where she was coming from. I connected with Aidan (is that his name?) a lot more. He was a cutie pie ❤ Ultimately, I did like how it ended because it ended the best way it possibly could. Best of both worlds (but at the same time, kind of unnecessary).

    Liked by 1 person

    • This is my first Jennifer E. Smith’s book! I think so, at least. What of her others is your favourite? Her writing style is easy enough and it was mostly just Clare who bugged me a bit, and I’d love to read more of her work. ❤

      And yeah, I do think you're right that it ended the best way it possibly could if they were to get together. I'm generally not a fan of old-lovers-getting-back-together, though, so maybe I'm just biased in the first place like that. :p

      Liked by 1 person

  2. Sad Skyscraping didn’t work for you. I just won it in a giveaway, so I hope I enjoy it. I do agree that verse doesn’t work for every book and maybe that was the case here. I’ve only read two verse novels so far – one I loved, the other I hated, but I think it really just depends on the story. Fun mini-reviews, thanks for sharing!

    Liked by 1 person

    • I hope you enjoy it too! I’ve read other, more positive reviews, and I know some people found that Skyscraping worked for them on levels that didn’t work for me. It’s definitely very subjective–the only verse novel that I enjoyed so far is Ellen Hopkins’ Crank, but even her other books I didn’t find as engaging.

      Thank you for coming by and do let me know how you go, I’d love to hear your thoughts! 🙂

      Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s