Book Review: Everything, Everything – Nicola Yoon


Title: Everything, Everything (2015)
Author: Nicola Yoon
Genre: Young Adult, Contemporary
Extent: 320 pages
Rating: ★★★☆☆
Review: For the first eighteen years of her life, Maddy Whittier has been cooped up at home, 24/7 365. She suffers from Severe Combined Immunodeficiency (SCID), which basically means that she’s allergic to everything and an allergic reaction could very well be fatal. Apart from online, she only interacts with her doctor mum, and her nurse Carla. When a family moves in to the house next to theirs, Maddy gets to know Olly, a literal boy-next-door with a penchant for parkour and high places. Suddenly, living her life just like this seems to not be enough anymore…

The idea behind this book really caught my attention. This is such a unique disease—approximately one in a million, literally—and it’s great to see authors taking on new challenges and bringing in new things instead of recycling the same things over and over again (cancer, depression, grief, loss, suicide, etc.). Not that those things aren’t important, of course, but there are plenty of books written on those subjects, and this one is new.

I was surprised by how much I liked Maddy. I mean, I wasn’t expecting to dislike her, certainly, but I also very rarely actively want to be a YA main protagonist’s friend, but I definitely wanted to with this one. Maybe it’s having experienced what she has experienced, but Maddy is strong and kind-hearted, with enough curiosity about the world that I find endearing. I really enjoyed her relationship with her mum (at least at first), Carla, and Olly, too.

This is a book where for once I didn’t care at all that the girl pretty much insta-loved the guy, whereas normally, that kind of thing would really turn me off. Given Maddy’s unique circumstances, it’s definitely understandable that she would fall for Olly, the one decent guy she actually got to see in real life. For what’s it worth, it surprisingly didn’t feel unnatural or forced at all. Olly is such a sweetheart, and I liked that he, too, came with his own set of problems that he had to work on his own.

The plot twist nearing the end surprised the living daylights out of me. I didn’t see it coming until the very last minute, and it felt so completely out of the left field that I had to take a moment to process it before I continued reading. Did I like it? That’s a harder question to answer. It did feel a bit like a cop-out from Yoon, and I agree with what other book bloggers have said that it cheapens the story somewhat.

Because of this, the ending didn’t quite satisfy me. There were too many things I needed to see before I could accept that it was The End, and some of these things were for Maddy’s mother to suffer some consequences for what she did (i.e. child abuse) and for Maddy to actually deal with her issues before jumping into a relationship. What happened was supposedly so traumatic for her, but she seemed to just brush it off and move on, which I didn’t think was realistic.

That being said, I liked the focus Yoon put on distinguishing between ‘being alive’ and ‘actually living life’. So often we tend to take things for granted—things as simple as walking on the grass, feeling the breeze, holding hands—not realising that to some people in the world, these things are a luxury. This is a great message, despite the unsatisfying ending.

Overall I found Everything, Everything to be an engaging, at-parts dramatic novel that will keep you turning the pages until the end. I read it in one sitting and greatly enjoyed the illustrations incorporated into the pages—apparently they were all done by Yoon’s husband!

14 thoughts on “Book Review: Everything, Everything – Nicola Yoon

  1. I loved this book but I agree with you about the ending. I felt like the whole thing was set up so that the romance would work. I would have preferred it if there was a bit more resolution with the whole thing with her mother. While I didn’t like the mother very much, I thought it was wrong of Maddy to just leave when it’s so obvious that her mum needed help.


    • Yeah, I feel like the ending was a bit of a cop-out and it cheapened the whole SCID theme–it made it unreal and was just too easy, if that makes sense. I didn’t like the mother very much as well, but she definitely needed help… and I also think Maddy probably needs to deal with these complications first before she starts a relationship. :/ What did you rate it?


  2. Great review! I agreed with you on pretty much everything. I liked the twist a lot, but I wish it had happened earlier because so much was left unresolved.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s